Louise McKenna’s post: the system of “identity” we live under

Sooo… ya know, most people go their whole lives without ever realising how recent and strange the system of “identity” we live under really is. We think birth certificates have always been here, like some timeless part of life, but they weren’t. They arrived after a massive reshaping of sovereignty, a reshaping that most people don’t know the first thing about. And at the very centre of that transformation stands one woman, Sophia of Hanover.
Before her, Europe was still ruled by the old Catholic dynasties, the kind of families that had held power for centuries. Even in England, the monarchy kept swinging between Protestant and Catholic claimants. The whole thing was chaotic. You had wars of succession, uprisings, plots, and rival royal houses all trying to claim the throne. Ireland, meanwhile, was caught in the middle of this constant power struggle, and Irish Catholics lived with the uncertainty of which religion the next monarch might impose.
Then comes 1701. Parliament steps in and makes one of the most aggressive constitutional moves in history. They pass the Act of Settlement, and with one stroke they ban all Catholics from ever ruling Britain or Ireland again. Not temporarily, permanently. They declare that if a monarch even married a Catholic, they would lose the crown. And then they select one specific woman, out of hundreds of potential heirs scattered across Europe, as the future of the monarchy, Sophia of Hanover.
Most people today couldn’t tell you who she was. But she sealed the deal. By naming her, a German Protestant duchess, as the legal ancestor of every future king and queen, Parliament locked the entire system of sovereignty into a permanent Protestant line. The Catholic Stuarts were finished. The Gaelic world lost whatever tiny leverage it had left. Ireland was pulled fully under a monarchy that would never again reflect its native people.
That moment shifted everything. From here on out, sovereignty wasn’t mystical or ancient or based on tradition. It became administrative. Parliamentary. Financial. It aligned itself with the emerging world of paperwork, banking, and bureaucracy. The Crown and Parliament didn’t just want to rule; they wanted to organise, to count, to catalogue, to track. They wanted a population they could see on paper.
And that’s where the story turns toward the birth certificate.
For centuries, the legal idea of the “juristic person” already existed, this artificial identity used by corporations, churches, towns, and even the Crown itself. But ordinary people weren’t plugged into that system. They were known only to their families or their parish. There was no universal registration of human beings. You lived, you married, you died, with no central file to define you.
But after the Protestant succession was secured, the empire transformed into a machine that needed records. Industrialisation was exploding, cities were booming, taxes were rising, and the state needed a way to attach every newborn to the administrative identity system it had been using for institutions for hundreds of years.
So in 1837, the first real civil birth certificates appear in England and Wales. Not ancient. Not medieval. 1837. Ireland followed later, in 1864. For the first time, every child was written into the state’s system at birth. The legal fiction that had once belonged only to corporations and royal bodies was applied to ordinary people from their very first breath.
Once that happened, the rest was just evolution. Census numbers, national insurance numbers, PPS numbers, passports, social security, digital identity, biometrics, CBDCs, AI identity management, it all flows from the same root. The state created a paper version of you, then a digital version of that paper, and now we’re watching it turn into something even more abstract.
But the beginning of that journey wasn’t the 20th century. It wasn’t computers. It wasn’t the EU or the UN. It began when sovereignty itself was rewritten, when the old Catholic and Gaelic orders were cut out of the picture and a new administrative monarchy rose in their place. The world we live in, the one where your existence is defined by a certificate, is the direct descendant of a power shift engineered in 1701 and carried forward by a German duchess whose name most people have forgotten.
If you ever feel like the modern identity system wasn’t built for you, it’s because it wasn’t. It was built for a state that wanted paperwork more than people. And once you see the timeline, the whole thing suddenly makes sense.